Activity Preferences in Psychotherapy: What Do Patients Want and How Does This Relate to Outcomes and Alliance?

This study aimed to investigate (a) what clients’ within-treatment activity preferences were;
(b) whether match between preferences and psychotherapy approach predicted outcomes and alliance;
(c) whether scores on preference dimensions, per se, predicted outcomes and alliance. Participants were 470 clients engaging in one of five approaches with trainee psychotherapists. We used the Cooper–Norcross Inventory of Preferences to identify clients’ within-treatment activity preferences; and multilevel modeling to examine the relationship between these preferences—and match on these preferences—to outcomes and alliance. Clients had an overall preference for therapist directiveness and emotional intensity. We found no evidence of a preference matching effect. Clients who expressed a desire for the focused challenge over warm support showed greater progress. Client preferences for focused challenge may be indicative of their readiness to change and indicate a positive prognosis.
Further research should directly observe therapeutic practices and assess a range of client
variables.